Campaign to Repeal Pathways

Printer-friendly version


Vote No Confidence in Pathways.

Voting by phone, website and by mail is fully functional.

Why I'm Voting No Confidence in Pathways.

(Click the name to find out why.)

AranzazuBorracheroPathways0513.jpgAránzazu
Borrachero
BlancheCookPathways0513.jpgBlanche Cook FrankDealePathways0513.jpgFrank Deale ManfredPhillipPathways0513.jpgManfred Philipp


Why a No Confidence vote, and why now? Read a message from PSC President Barbara Bowen.

Scheduled to begin in the fall of 2013, Pathways is a university-wide revamp of CUNY’s general education curriculum—a policy governing the number and types of classes all students must complete. It was enacted by the CUNY Board of Trustees with the supposed purpose of smoothing transfer between CUNY colleges. The real agenda behind Pathways, as President Barbara Bowen has shown, is about spending less per student and graduating more students in a shorter time at lower cost. Thousands of CUNY faculty oppose Pathways because it diminishes the quality of a CUNY education.

Vote No Confidence: May 9 -31 | Why A No Confidence Vote? | Pathways Fact Sheet | Pathways' Real Agenda| Clarion Coverage | Ad Campaign |Pathways Moratorium Resolution |Pathways Lawsuits |Members Testify Against Pathways | Threats & Coercion at QCC | AAUP on Pathways| MLA on Pathways | Pathways Watch Emails | Timeline: Resistance to Pathways

More in This Section

You may now vote in the Pathways referendum!

Voting by phone, website and by mail is fully functional. All problems are resolved, and the votes have been coming in. American Arbitration Association will be contacting full-time faculty directly to apologize for the series of errors on their part that led to the system failures over the weekend. President Barbara Bowen emailed this message to full-time faculty on Monday, May 13 to add her apologies on their behalf.

Vote No Confidence in Pathways May 9 - 31

Ads Deale
This is a sample of the online ad PSC launched to support the No Confidence in Pathways campaign. The link isn't activated. For the paid ad, the link would take you to this URL: psc-cuny.org/pathwaysvote.
Full-time faculty will receive in the mail a secret ballot for a referendum on a motion of No Confidence in Pathways. Ballots will be mailed on Wed., May 8, and voting will take place Thurs., May 9 - Fri., May 31.

The vote will be conducted by the American Arbitration Association. Full-time faculty may vote online, by telephone and by mail. If you haven’t received a ballot by Monday, May 13, contact Barbara Gabriel.

Why a No Confidence Vote, and Why Now?

See how to vote No Confidence in Pathways.

A message from Dr. Barbara Bowen, president of the PSC

April 25, 2013

Dear Colleague,

In a few days you will receive in the mail a secret ballot for a referendum on a motion of No Confidence in Pathways. Voting by secret ballot takes place from May 9 to May 31. I urge you to participate in the referendum and to vote in support of the No Confidence motion.

Why a No Confidence vote, and why now? Because this is the strategic moment to send a message to the incoming CUNY administration in a form they cannot ignore—and because the opposition to Pathways is so profound that it merits a No Confidence vote.

National Petition for a Moratorium on Pathways

Sign the Petition and Spread the Word!

PSC and UFS are launching a national petition calling for an immediate moratorium on all further implementation of Pathways. The fight against the cheapening of a CUNY education is not just a local fight. Higher education “reforms” similar to Pathways—some even with the same name—are moving forward throughout the nation. All of us in the field of higher education—especially those who serve at public institutions—have reason to be concerned by recent trends in higher education policy. Please sign the petition yourself and then forward it to your colleagues nationally and internationally, with a personal invitation to sign.

En Français

En Español

Barbara Bowen and Lexa Logue on WNYC

"The conflict spilled into view this week, with ads published in several newspapers" reported WNYC's and National Public Radio's "All Things Considered" in a story about Pathways on March 21st.. Click here to listen to PSC President Barbara Bowen and CUNY Provost and Executive Vice Chancellor Lexa Logue interviewed by WNYC's Amy Eddings.

Pathways Ad Campaign

Renowned CUNY Faculty Speak Out in Ad Campaign Against Pathways

Dr. Philipp, a twice-honored Senior Fulbright Scholar and biochemist with significant biomedical patents to his name, is featured in the campaign alongside other faculty. His ad says: “[Pathways] limits students’ exposure to new ideas and robs them of opportunities to discover new talents and passions, cutting costs by sacrificing rigor and educational quality.”

PathwaysFaculty Ad Philipp.jpg

Modern Language Association Vote Opposing Pathways

The Delegate Assembly of the Modern Language Association passed a resolution opposing Pathways at their January meeting in Boston. The organization serves a membership of 30,000 English and foreign language faculty in 100 countries. According to Inside Higher Ed, the resolution “criticiz[es] the CUNY administration at the City University of New York, arguing that administrators infringed on faculty rights in creating and requiring a curricular system to ease transfer from the system's community colleges to its four-year institutions.” It goes on to support a moratorium on implementation of the new curriculum. The resolution now goes to the MLA’s executive committee for review and to the full membership for a vote. (Read more on the Inside Higher Ed website.)

Timeline: Resistance to Pathways

The campaign against Pathways, CUNY’s top-down overhaul of general education and transfer, began with a town hall meeting on March 8, 2012. By the end of the following month, 5,676 members of the CUNY community had signed a petition calling for repeal. CUNY faculty and staff in their departments and campus governance bodies engaged the issue. Two lawsuits were filed -- and resistance continued to grow.

Pathways Step 2 Grievance

On Friday, November 9 PSC presented the following argument in a Step 2 Grievance hearing on Pathways. Dozens of PSC members attended the hearing overflowing from the hearing room to a rally outside the building.

Victory for shared governance: QCC English department’s department chair vote will stand

The Academe blog and the GC Advocate have posted news of an important reversal from Queensborough Community College President Diane Call. Last week, President Call informed the English department on that campus that she planned to reject their near three-fourths majority vote to elect a new chair. The struggles of the QCC English department made headlines recently when faculty members were threatened with mass firings after the department voted against reducing classroom hours for Pathways-compliant composition courses.

Over the weekend and on Monday, more than 900 CUNY faculty signed a petition from the QCC English department faculty urging President Call to reconsider her decision to deny their vote for chair.

This morning, President Call sent the following message to members of the QCC English department:

Colleagues—

It is my decision to accept the recommendation forwarded by the English Department for Dr. David Humphries to serve as its Chairperson, effective November 14, 2012.

In a lengthy meeting with Dr. Humphries yesterday, he expressed his willingness and ability to advance the important work of the English Department in curricular and personnel matters. I have confidence in and appreciate his sincerity to unite the department as a community, in the best interests of the College and our students.

Thank you.
Dr. Diane B. Call
Interim President
Queensborough Community College

CUNY Must Honor the Results of Department Chair Elections

The PSC fully supports the right of CUNY faculty to elect their department chairs, as established in the CUNY bylaws. When faculty vote to make a change in their department leadership, as happened recently with the English department at Queensborough Community College (QCC), the college president should accept the results of the vote and honor the wishes of the faculty.

Diane Call, the president of QCC, has informed the English department on that campus that she will reject their near three-fourths majority vote to elect a new chair.

Hundreds of CUNY faculty have signed a petition from the QCC English department faculty urging President Call to reconsider her decision to deny their vote for chair. Please add your name to the petition.

College of Staten Island Faculty Senate demands moratorium on Pathways

Another college curriculum-approving body has taken a stand against Pathways.

On Thursday, November 8, the Faculty Senate of the College of Staten Island passed a resolution holding that it would “not compromise academic rigor and quality of curricula at CSI.” The resolution says that the “majority of full time faculty, department chairs, and members of the faculty governance and related committees continue to oppose Pathways” and calls for a “moratorium on all matters related to Pathways implementation.” Read the CSI Faculty Senate resolution.

The CSI faculty are following the lead of the union’s Delegate Assembly

Bronx students hold forum on Pathways

The Political Science Club at Bronx Community College sponsored a forum on Pathways on Wed., Nov. 7 to examine the impact Pathways will have on students. One hundred students attended the event, which featured reports from a student, two department chairs and the BCC dean of student success, followed by a question and answer session.

Opposition to Pathways Intensifies; PSC Goes to Court to Stop the Initiative

The battle over Pathways is also being waged in this courts. Two PSC-UFS lawsuits are working their way through the court system. One argues that the CUNY administration exceeded its authority in matters of curriculum and failed to follow university bylaws and faculty governance procedures. The other contends that CUNY has advanced Pathways in violation of the State's Open Meetings Law.

UFS/PSC Conference about Pathways

The CUNY-wide discussions on resisting Pathways and developing alternatives to it continued on Friday, October 12 with a conference of UFS and PSC researchers. The gathering put the Pathways struggle in the context of a national push to corporatize universities. Transfer systems at other large public university systems were examined, the PSC/UFS Alternative to Pathways Working Group gave an update, and researchers presented their findings. One panel shared research debunking a major rationale for Pathways: that transfer problems are the primary reason some CUNY students accumulate excess credits. Click here to read the report.

The conference ended with PSC President Barbara Bowen explaining the union’s call for a moratorium on the implementation of Pathways. After the threatened reprisals at QCC and elsewhere, only a pause and “reset” of the Pathways discussion can allow the damage to academic freedom and open deliberation at CUNY to be repaired.

Unity and Resolve at Meeting of Community College English Department Faculty

Unity is our best defense and we will not stand for coercion. That was the message last week when dozens of faculty from English departments at CUNY community colleges met to discuss a collective response to the threats of reprisal they have received as they vote on Composition courses for Pathways. At the meeting, union leaders reiterated the PSC’s commitment to defend members from retaliation and outlined the contractual and legal basis for the faculty’s right to exercise their academic judgment by voting on curriculum matters. They also shared a resolution condemning the threats, which was passed recently by the Delegate Assembly.

AAUP on Pathways

The American Association of University Professors, a national affiliate of the PSC, has weighed in on Pathways several times. They have warned CUNY against attacks on academic freedom and shared governance and raised faculty objections. Most recently, AAUP has written CUNY about the "inhospitable climate for academic freedom and faculty governance suggested by the resort to threats [at QCC]."

Resolution Demanding a Moratorium on Pathways

At the September Delegate Assembly meeting, the delegates passed a resolution reiterating the PSC's demand for the repeal of Pathways and calling for an immediate moratorium on all further implementation until the CUNY Central Administration explicitly withdraws all forms of coercion and pressure directed at faculty, staff, departments and other governance bodies. The PSC encourages faculty senates, disciplinary councils, departments and other governance bodies to adopt or adapt this resolution as they see fit.

Pathways at QCC

On Wednesday, September 12th, the English Department at Queensborough Community College voted overwhelmingly to reject proposed curriculum changes for Pathways, namely a reduction of hours for English composition courses from four to three. The faculty’s decision was guided by a deep commitment to sustaining a quality education for students.

The administration's response, an email to the department the next day by Vice President Karen Steele, announced sweeping reprisals. The email threatened eliminating all composition courses, cancelling all English Department searches, calling all full-time faculty reappointments in fall 2013 into question, and announcing that all adjunct faculty will be sent non-reappointment letters in fall 2013.

The response to Steele's email was swift, intense and both CUNY-wide and national. Condemnation came not only from the PSC, but also from CUNY's English Discipline Council, from other CUNY English department faculty, and from the AAUP. Media coverage, both local and national, both mass circulation and educational, was extensive.

Update on threatened reprisals at QCC: PSC responds to VP Steele's public apology

Read the PSC’s update on the reprisals that Queensborough Community College Vice President Karen Steele announced after the English Department voted ‘no’ on three-hour, three-credit composition courses for Pathways.

QCC Chapter Chair's Response to Vice-President's Apology

Read QCC Chapter Chair Judy Barbanel's response to Vice President Steele's apology regarding reprisals against the English Department.

PSC Response to Pathways Reprisals

Read the PSC’s response to the outrageous reprisals Queensborough Community College Vice President Karen Steele announced after the English Department voted ‘no’ on three-hour, three-credit composition courses for Pathways. What happened at Queensborough is important for all of us.

Members Speak Out Against Pathways

Thirty CUNY faculty and staff presented testimony about problems with Pathways at the June 18 CUNY Board of Trustees borough hearing. Their testimony offered a varied and detailed analysis of how Pathways would hurt students and undermine the value of the CUNY degree.

Read their testimony.

A Real Transfer Process for CUNY Students

Petitions with 5,676 signatures were delivered to the Board.
IMG_7925.jpg

University Faculty Senate Sandi Cooper and Professional Staff Congress President Barbara Bowen released a statement today on May 16th announcing a major effort to develop an alternative to Pathways.

This UFS/PSC initiative comes after a campaign that gathered thousands of petition signatures. On April 30th, at the CUNY Board of Trustees meeting, the PSC presented the petition calling for the repeal and replacement of Pathways, CUNY’s new austerity-inspired General Education framework. 5,676 faculty and staff have signed the petition, which was delivered to each CUNY trustee and college president and displayed on big signs at the Board meeting.

Pathways Watch

Pathways Watch is the source for news on the growing opposition to Pathways. Watch this space for updates on how people across the University—and beyond—are speaking out against Pathways and demanding an alternative.

Pathways Videos

Nearly 350 faculty, staff and students attended a March 8th PSC Town Hall Meeting on Pathways, the City University of New York's (CUNY's) top-down overhaul of general education and transfer.

We capture part of that event in video excerpts from two of the speakers, PSC President Barbara Bowen and Terrence Martell, Vice Chair UFS and Saxe Distinguished Professor of Finance, Baruch College.

Sign the Petition to Repeal Pathways

On April 30th, the petition with 5,676 signatures was presented to the CUNY Board. Click here for the full list of signatories presented to the Board. (Most signed online. Several hundred more signed hard copies of the petition.)

Town Hall Meeting: Speaking Out on Pathways, Organizing for an Alternative

Sign the petition! | March Clarion coverage of Pathways controversy | Town Hall Photos |

Nearly 350 faculty, staff and students attended a PSC Town Hall Meeting on Pathways, CUNY’s top-down overhaul of general education and transfer. About 30 people spoke during an hour-long open mic, criticizing Pathways and demanding an alternative.